Temporary Archive: Suzanne Brockmann's Message Board

Back to Archive Index

just start hurling the stones now

Posted by Erika on 10/19/2005, 19:14:06, in reply to "Delurking and question about honor in US Military"
Nope. I really don't think that people in the military are any better or any worse than in any other large cross section of society. There are liars and thieves everywhere as well as honorable, just, responsible people.

I'm willing to believe that some specific groups in the military self select for certain traits which would tend to skew the distribution of more/less desirable traits off the average, but for the military as a whole? Same as non-military.

Also, I don't think serving in the military makes one more honorable than someone else, or more honorable than they were before they joined. For instance, I don't think Suz is any less honorable than a member of the military just because she doesn't serve the country in that specific manner. And you'll notice she does have less than admirable military people in her books - the worst being Admiral *ucker. Ostensibly, the *=T, but we all know better. (Andrea, does this violate the no swearing code?)

I heard a quote on a news show last year where a newscaster said that one thing he learned from being in the military is that not everyone in the military is a hero. It stayed with me, but probably because I agree. I read Suz and C.Mann's books in spite of their military heroes, though, not because of it. I had a year in AFROTC and while I met some amazing people in ROTC and the regular Air Force (here's hoping Major Levias is nearing General now), I also met one of the stupidest colonels ever and a lot of people I didn't respect in the slightest. But I could say the same of people in any large group of people.

-Erika


Responses:


Temporarily archived without permission from Suzanne Brockmann's Message Board.
Contact Donna if questions or concerns.