Temporary Archive: Suzanne Brockmann's Message Board

third and fourth questions

Posted by tom on 10/11/2005, 8:16:34, in reply to "Re: No airconditioning "

why are the held in GITMO? In WWII with a genocide going on, where and in what conditions were German POWs of the US held?

Responses:

Question # 4 - Kristy 10/11/2005, 15:21:19
Question # 3 - Kristy 10/11/2005, 15:08:34
Tom answers to your questions - lisa A 10/11/2005, 11:13:22
- This goes back - Tom 10/11/2005, 16:43:35
  - I don't think it's a minority opnion - Deborah 10/11/2005, 17:00:54
    - Yes I do - Tom 10/11/2005, 17:20:05
      - I'm not talking about - Deborah 10/11/2005, 17:50:02
Re: third and fourth questions - KarenT 10/11/2005, 10:23:02
- so - Tom 10/11/2005, 10:29:35
  - Tom, have any soldiers challenged as being legal - Kristy 10/11/2005, 15:48:39
    - Not to my knowledge - tom 10/11/2005, 17:24:14
      - Can't they refuse - Deborah 10/11/2005, 17:52:08
  - Because Americans sat as judges at The Nuremberg Trials - Kristy 10/11/2005, 15:43:25
  - Standard of Proof - KarenT 10/11/2005, 10:45:30
  - to circumvent the constitution - Deborah 10/11/2005, 10:33:39
well no a/c wasn't their biggest complaint - Deborah 10/11/2005, 9:09:26
- How might that affect - Tom 10/11/2005, 10:39:52
  - Re: How might that affect - Kristy 10/11/2005, 15:57:35
  - I think the damage - Deborah 10/11/2005, 10:47:46
  - American POWs? - Chris (FL) 10/11/2005, 10:46:31
    - Not really my point - tom 10/11/2005, 10:53:55
  - That would be assuming that what we do would in any way... - Andrea 10/11/2005, 10:43:20
    - Re: That would be assuming that what we do would in any way... - KarenT 10/11/2005, 10:52:27
      - They are prisoners and should be treated that way - Chris (FL) 10/11/2005, 10:57:38
        
        Remember Amy Fisher - Lisa A 10/11/2005, 13:13:04
    - You are correct - tom 10/11/2005, 10:49:26
      - to clarify... - Andrea 10/11/2005, 10:50:46
        
        I mean that - Tom 10/11/2005, 10:56:37
        
        Re: I mean that - Chris (FL) 10/11/2005, 11:23:28
        
        Doesn't an enemy win if they can successfully change our standard of behavior? - Kristy 10/11/2005, 16:02:14
        
        not really my point at all.... - Chris (FL) 10/11/2005, 16:19:28
        
        generally you are correct - tom 10/11/2005, 17:41:14
- ah hah!..we have - Chris (FL) 10/11/2005, 10:08:23

Temporarily archived without permission from Suzanne Brockmann's Message Board.
Contact Donna if questions or concerns.